Galaxy Quest Gives Its Jokes a Job to Do

By Paul Michael Durivage

Spoilers for Galaxy Quest follow.

The best jokes in Galaxy Quest keep causing problems after we have laughed. A ridiculous job description becomes somebody’s responsibility. An actor’s embarrassment becomes another person’s hope. A fan who knows far too much about a television show turns out to know something the heroes urgently need.

That is a large part of why this 1999 comedy still works as an adventure. Its jokes give the characters something to do, and sometimes something difficult to admit.

The premise supplies a wonderfully unfair test. The Thermians have mistaken a cancelled science-fiction series for a record of actual events. They build a working version of its spaceship and recruit the actors to help them against Sarris. Jason Nesmith and his fellow performers arrive with the appearance of competence. The people depending on them have very little reason to question it.

Once the misunderstanding becomes dangerous, the film has a choice. It could keep finding new ways for the actors to be useless. Instead, it asks what their strange experience might actually be worth.

Consider Gwen DeMarco, played by Sigourney Weaver. On the old show, her character mostly repeated information supplied by the computer. She knows how thin that part was. Aboard the Thermians’ ship, she finds herself repeating the computer again.

The repetition is funny because she can hear herself doing it. She is trapped inside a piece of television writing she has already outgrown. Yet she also insists on doing the job available to her. Weaver gives the irritation a practical edge. Someone still has to communicate the information while everyone else argues.

There is useful character writing in that irritation. Gwen does not need a speech explaining that she deserves a better part. Her impatience tells us what she thinks of the old one. Her continued participation tells us something else about her. The joke allows both responses to exist together, so she remains a person rather than a complaint about a familiar television convention.

Guy Fleegman, Sam Rockwell’s anxious former extra, makes another convention painfully personal. Because his old character existed to be killed, he expects to die on the real mission. Later, Fred suggests he might be the comic relief instead.

Guy’s fear gives the joke movement. Every unfamiliar place presents him with another possible explanation for how he will die. His knowledge of stories is useful enough to make him watchful and unreliable enough to keep him terrified. He cannot tell whether he has recognized a warning or merely frightened himself with a pattern.

That uncertainty is much more engaging than a character who keeps announcing the correct trope. A person who always knows the rules can flatten a scene by explaining it before it happens. Guy’s understanding produces behavior we can watch. It affects where he wants to stand and whether he wants to stay behind. We laugh at the certainty with which he predicts his own insignificance, while the amount of attention the film gives him quietly argues against it.

The fans’ detailed knowledge gets a different treatment. Jason initially dismisses Brandon’s technical questions. Later, Brandon and his friends help guide Jason and Gwen through the ship.

The reversal works because the earlier encounter has left something unfinished between them. Jason needs information, but he also needs help from someone he treated badly. Asking for that help changes the relationship. The person at the autograph table can now contribute something the famous actor cannot supply.

This is also where the film’s affection for fandom becomes concrete. We do not have to accept an announcement that passionate viewers matter. Their attention becomes useful within the action. The pleasure comes from seeing a supposedly excessive interest meet a situation in which it is exactly the right interest to have. A joke about knowing too much acquires a second meaning without losing the first.

Galaxy Quest remains willing to find absurdity in the material those fans love. The crushing machinery Jason and Gwen must cross is particularly hard to defend as sensible spaceship design. Gwen objects even as they have to get through it.

Her objection does not remove the obstacle. That matters. A film can become weightless when pointing out a ridiculous situation excuses it from making the situation consequential. Here the complaint adds another source of friction. Gwen can recognize bad design and still be endangered by it. Her awareness gives us permission to laugh without asking us to stop caring whether she survives.

The most affecting return belongs to Alexander Dane, Alan Rickman’s weary actor. He despises his alien character’s catchphrase. When the dying Quellek tells him how much that character has meant to him, Alexander finally speaks the promise of vengeance with conviction.

Rickman does not have to persuade us that the words have become better dialogue. Their recipient has changed what it costs to say them. Earlier, Alexander hears a reminder of work he resents. Now he is faced with someone who found courage in that work. Whatever he thinks of the role, he can choose what to give this person.

The scene trusts us to remember the joke. It does not apologize for having made us laugh at Alexander’s disgust, and it does not protect us with another gag at the moment when his tenderness matters. The earlier laughter gives the change somewhere to begin.

That is the craft lesson I take from Galaxy Quest. When a comic detail returns, its purpose can change. The same habit might embarrass a character in one scene and help someone in another. A familiar line can become difficult to say for a new reason. The audience remembers the first use and brings that memory to the second.

For a writer, the useful question is what the joke leaves behind. If the answer is an obligation, a fear or an uncomfortable relationship, there may be more story available. Galaxy Quest keeps picking those things up. By the time its actors have to behave like heroes, the comedy has helped give them reasons to try.

Author bio:

Paul Michael Durivage is a Michigan author and lifelong machinist whose books include The Crossing and Is the Apocalypse a Valid Use of Sick Days? His work is at paulmichaeldurivage.com.

The Crossing

By Paul Michael Durivage

HE LEFT THE HOUSE. IT NEVER LEFT HIM.

As a child, Evan slept behind a locked door while wet footsteps crossed the hall. His parents called it the pipes. He knew better.

Evan grew up, left Connecticut, and built a life with Sarah and their daughter, Lily. Now he works with the Church, helping families confront things they cannot explain. Sarah knows how much his work has taken from their marriage. She does not know how much of his own past he is still keeping from her.

Then a call brings him home to Ripley, Ohio. A young woman is badly injured inside St. Jude’s. She is speaking in the voice of a priest’s dead mother.

Evan recognizes the black water. The river mud. The demon that knows where to hurt him.

As he fights to free Emily Hart, Sarah hears their daughter’s voice calling from an empty room. Lily is standing beside her, holding her hand. The danger has followed Evan home.

To save Emily without losing his family, Evan will have to trust people he cannot keep safe and stop deciding what they can bear to know.

Buy Now from Amazon.com: Print | Kindle

Profile photo of axiomsedgescifi
Author: axiomsedgescifi

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *